Menu
Carl Camera

Expression vs CS3 Pricing

As someone who expressed recent interest in jumping into Flash development, the announcements and demos at Mix07 have significantly altered my software purchasing outlook.

I cannot and will not comment on whether Silverlight
is a Flash Killer but I can provide one data point and reasoning for my interest in Silverlight as well as my corresponding disinterest in Flash.

I'm not a big design shop, but I'm getting more and more requests from clients and potential clients about developing photo galleries and other miscellaneous requests for stuff-that-moves.

The logical step would be to move from Photoshop CS up to Creative Studio 3 Web Premium, that provides image and vector-based design, web editor, and Flash IDE. I could upgrade to Photoshop CS3, Illustrator CS3, Flash CS3, Dreamweaver CS3, and Fireworks CS3 bundled into a package called CS3 Web Premium for a mere $1560.

As an existing Adobe Photoshop CS owner, however, I am eligible for the CS3 Web Premium Upsell product at only $1370. Even at that upsell price, I would have to delay plans for new hardware.

Microsoft, on the other hand, is offering image and vector-based design, web editor, and Silverlight IDE. I can get the inaugural editions of Expression Web, Expression Design, Expression Blend, plus Visual Studio 2005 Standard for $560 in a package called Expression Studio. As an existing Expression Web owner, I am eligible for an upgrade price of $330. Hmm. Maybe I could afford that new notebook computer come Christmas.

This is quite a big decision because it means abandoning my Photoshop roots for a new design paradigm. Nevertheless, I'm faced with a purchase decision of $330 or $1370. Am I under the influence of the Microsoft Kool-Aid or is this a compelling design-development solution at a significantly lower price?

Note: All prices are Amazon.com prices as of 11 May 2007.

Comments